Welcome to Shirley's Sweet Potato Pies
thank you for stopping by!

The Best in the Midwest!

Shirley's Sweet Potato Pies are specialty pies that are handmade from scratch with only the highest quality ingredients. We take real butter and fresh eggs and mix them together with the finest ingredients into a rich smooth batter. Our pies have that down home taste and baked to perfection.

Serve one of our delicious pies to your guests or take one of our pies to your next pot luck, family get together, birthday holiday, or special events.

Our specialty are sweet potato pies, and we also offer cheese cakes, bundt cakes and cupcakes.

Our desserts are available for sale to restaurants, ice cream shops, coffee shops and other dining venues throughout Columbus, Ohio. Wholesale pricing available upon request.

How to Place Your Order

1. Call us (614) 893-4141.

2. Email us with your order or any questions.

3. Coming soon you'll be able to place your order online and have items shipped to your front door!

Email us today to get started!



At Shirley’s all pies are baked from scratch using fresh peeled yams with all the ingredients consistency like mom’s baked pies.

  • 10” Deep Dish 8 servings $17.99

  • 9” Deep Dish 7 servings $15.99

  • 3” Mini 1 serving $ 2.59

  • 4” Slice 1 serving $ 3.59

  • 5” Mini 2 servings $ 6.99

  • ADD $2.50 additional for Pecans

  • ADD $2.00 additional for Sugar Free Splenda


New York Style and Sweet Potato - All Cheesecakes are made with a graham cracker crust


  • Sweet Potato & New York Style 
  • Fruit Topping: Cherry/Strawberry/Apple/Blueberry
  • 10” 8 servings $31.99 - ADD $2.50 additional for fruit topping
  • 8” 6 servings $26.99 - ADD $2.00 additional for fruit topping
  • 3” 2 servings $3.99 - ADD $.10 additional for fruit topping


  • 2” Mini Bite Size 3 for $6.00 - ADD $0.30 additional for fruit topping
  • 2” Mini Bite Size 12 for $20.00 - ADD $1.50 additional for fruit topping


FLAVORS: Butter, Yellow, Chocolate and Lemon

  • Butter $18.00

  • Yellow, Chocolate and Lemon $15.00

**All prices are subject to change without notice**

**All cakes may be purchased with or without creamy icing**